Monetize

How to turn a fitness challenge into a subscription

How to turn a fitness challenge into a subscription: reuse its workouts, invite the people who bought it, and launch with your next challenge.

Eden Metzler Senior Marketing Specialist @edenmetzler

If you already sell a fitness challenge, you can turn it into a subscription without starting over. Your challenge workouts become your first program, the people who bought it become your first subscribers, and your next challenge becomes the launch.

That matters if you live on launches. Every challenge brings money in, then it stops until the next one. A subscription keeps paying in between.

You can keep selling the challenge on its own, too. The subscription sits next to it.

What you already have

A challenge that sells already has the three things a subscription needs: content people paid for, people who paid you, and a group that showed up. The table shows where each one goes.

From your challengeIn your subscription
The challenge workoutsYour first program, plus categories built from the same workouts
Your daily scheduleNew content on a schedule you can keep, like new workouts every week
The challenge groupYour subscription community
The people who bought itYour first subscribers
Your challenge dateA challenge a few times a year, inside the subscription

Make the challenge your first program

Rename the challenge after the result it gets people, and make it the first program new subscribers see. Keep the same workouts and the same voice.

Take out the countdown and the deadline language (people can now start it any day).

Build categories from the same workouts

Copy the challenge workouts into a few categories, sorted the way people pick a workout on a busy day:

  • By time, like a 20-minute session.
  • By equipment, like at home with no weights.
  • By focus, like a lower-body day or a mobility session.

That’s more to choose from, with no new filming.

You don’t need a huge library to launch. Build what a new subscriber needs for their first week and their first program, and plan the rest.

Add a “start here”

Give new subscribers one place to begin. Say who the subscription is for, which program to start with, how to use the app, how to get help, and what’s coming next.

Point them at one workout to do first. In Playbook’s data, new subscribers who finish a workout on their first day or the next are more likely to still be paying months later.

Pick a schedule you can keep

New workouts on a set day are what most subscriptions run on. If you think in six-week blocks, keep them, and release them a week at a time.

Can’t film every week? Add a new program each month, or plan your next challenge each quarter. Whatever you pick, say it in “start here” and keep it.

In Playbook’s data, creators who add new content on a set schedule keep their subscribers better.

Move the challenge group in

The group that showed up during the challenge becomes your subscription community. Same people, same check-ins, and now it doesn’t end. Here’s how to run a community that keeps subscribers paying.

Offer monthly and annual, with a free trial

Set up two plans, monthly and annual, with a free trial in front of both. Our guide on how to sell fitness programs online covers the setup, and here’s whether to offer a free trial.

Turn on the automations

On Playbook, every automation starts off, so switch on the two that matter here:

  • One-time buyer to subscriber. It invites anyone who buys a one-off program to join your subscription. It points to your main subscription, so set that up first, and it only reaches people who buy after you turn it on.
  • Monthly to annual upgrade. It invites monthly subscribers to switch to annual before a renewal. It needs a monthly and an annual price, and it runs at most twice per subscriber.

Start with your past buyers

The people who already bought your challenge are your warmest list. They paid you, did the work, and know how you coach. The automation won’t reach them, so invite them yourself.

Send a personal invitation that covers three things:

  • What the subscription is, in one sentence.
  • What’s in it from week one: the program they know, what’s new and when (like new workouts every week), and the group.
  • A bonus only past challengers get, like an extra program or a better first month.

Show monthly and annual side by side. In Playbook’s data, the annual plan does more to keep people than a deep discount does.

Example email inviting people who did a creator's challenge to join the subscription, with a placeholder bonus, monthly and yearly options, and a Join now button.
An example invitation to past challenge buyers: what’s in it, a bonus for having done the challenge, and both plans.

Will they pay every month?

If you’ve sold challenges, you’ve probably asked yourself this. In our experience, past buyers are much more likely to say yes when:

  • They’ve already bought from you, so the subscription is the next step with someone they know.
  • They can see what’s in it from week one.
  • They know they can cancel easily, because you said so right next to the price.

Not everyone will join. And that’s fine. A smaller group who stays is worth more than a bigger list you only hear from at launch time.

Run the next challenge inside the subscription

Make your next challenge part of the subscription. To join, people start the subscription. When the challenge ends, they’re already subscribers, and the library is right there.

Your original challenge can stay on sale as a one-off program. The next one you run lives inside the subscription.

On Playbook, a challenge is a program in your app, so it can live inside your subscription. Feature it on your sales page so new people see it. Here’s how to set up a challenge on Playbook.

In Playbook’s data, challenge periods bring in more new subscribers, and more returning ones, than a creator’s usual weeks.

Set the dates

  • Tell your past buyers about the subscription first.
  • Open challenge sign-ups about a week before the start.
  • Keep them open through the first week, for anyone who’s late.
  • Close sign-ups when you said you would. If the deadline moves, people stop believing the next one.

Closing sign-ups doesn’t stop people joining your subscription. Anyone who joins after registration closes gets the workouts, but can’t register for the challenge itself.

Timeline for launching a subscription with your next challenge: invite past buyers, open sign-ups about a week before the start, the challenge runs with everyone already subscribed, and the day after brings a start here, the next goal and the next challenge date.

Make the day after feel like the next step

When the challenge ends, give everyone one clear next step, with a “start here”, their next goal and the date of the next challenge. Our guide to lifecycle marketing for fitness creators covers the messages to send in the first weeks.

Three or four a year, inside the subscription

We recommend three or four challenges a year, about one a quarter, with the dates set a quarter ahead. Each one gives new people a reason to join now, and gives current subscribers a reason to show up.

Give each challenge a short email sequence:

  • Sign-ups are open.
  • Last chance to join.
  • The workouts are live.
  • A check-in halfway through.
  • After-photos are open.

Do I have to stop selling my challenge on its own?

No. If it sells, keep it. Once you turn on the one-time buyer to subscriber automation, it invites each new buyer to join your subscription.

How much content do I need to turn a fitness challenge into a subscription?

Enough for a new subscriber’s first week and first program. Your challenge workouts cover most of that, and categories built from them fill out the library. Plan the rest.

Will people who bought my challenge pay every month?

They’re much more likely to if they can see what’s in it from week one, get a bonus for having done your challenge, and know they can cancel easily. Invite them personally, since the automation only reaches new buyers.

Can I run the same challenge again inside my subscription?

Yes. Run it a few times a year, as the event that brings new people in. Refresh the workouts or the goal, so returning subscribers get something new.

Keep adding to the subscription

A challenge brings people in. The subscription keeps them because you keep adding to it, with new content on the schedule you set, a community you show up in, and the next challenge on the calendar. That’s ongoing work, and it’s the work that keeps people paying.

If you’d like somewhere to run it, Playbook is an app built for fitness and wellness creators, with challenges and subscriptions in the same place. Playbook also has a team of fitness business experts that helps creators launch and grow. There’s no upfront cost.

Related articles

Monetize

Your best Black Friday yet: 10 lessons for fitness creators

Eden Metzler
Read full story
Grow

Lifecycle marketing for fitness creators: how to send emails that boost your revenue

Eden Metzler
Read full story
Launch

How to create a fitness app: from decision to launch, step by step

Jaimie Chapman
Read full story

Turn your audience into income.
We’ll show you how.

Start today. Especially if you don’t feel ready. Fear of failure kills fitness businesses before they even start. Sign-up’s quick and easy. You don’t pay a cent till you make a sale.

No credit card · No monthly fee · Cancel anytime